Co-ownership Type Comparison Tool
Understand the differences between co-ownership structures to make informed decisions about property investment.
Joint Tenancy
Ideal for spouses or close family members who want equal ownership and survivorship rights.
- All owners have equal shares
- Automatic inheritance upon death
- Requires consent to sell shares
Tenancy in Common
Suitable for friends or investors who want flexible ownership with unequal shares.
- Unequal ownership shares allowed
- No automatic inheritance
- Independent sale of shares
Shared Equity
Helpful for first-time buyers with limited deposits through third-party equity partners.
- Third-party investor involved
- Future profit sharing required
- Lower upfront capital needed
Detailed Comparison Table
| Feature | Joint Tenancy | Tenancy in Common | Shared Equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ownership Shares | Equal only | Unequal allowed | Owner + third-party investor |
| Right of Survivorship | Yes | No | No (investor’s stake defined in contract) |
| Selling Individual Share | Requires consent of all owners | Can sell without consent (subject to agreement) | Investor may have first-refusal clause |
| Mortgage Liability | Joint and several | Proportional to equity share | Investor typically not a borrower |
| Best For | Spouses, close family | Friends, investors, blended families | First-time buyers with low deposit |
Key Considerations
Before choosing a co-ownership structure, consider:
- Your relationship with co-owners
- Long-term plans and potential changes
- Financial capacity and risk tolerance
- Legal requirements and potential conflicts
When to Choose Each
Important Notes
- A written agreement is essential for all structures
- Legal consultation is highly recommended
- Mortgage implications vary by structure
- Tax consequences differ per ownership type
Note: This tool provides general information only. Consult a legal or financial advisor for specific advice.
Key Takeaways
- Co-ownership lets two or more people own a property together while keeping separate financial responsibilities.
- Joint tenancy provides survivorship rights; tenancy in common does not.
- Shared equity schemes are a hybrid that combines ownership with a lender’s stake.
- Clear legal agreements and mortgage structures prevent disputes.
- Understanding tax and exit options helps you protect your investment.
What is Co-ownership?
Co-ownership is a legal arrangement where two or more parties hold title to the same piece of real estate.
Each owner has a percentage share that reflects how much they contributed, but the exact split can be customized in the agreement. The concept is popular among friends, families, and even investors who want to pool resources to enter the market earlier.
Unlike renting, co-owners share both the benefits (like equity growth) and the costs (mortgage, maintenance, taxes). Proper planning is essential because the relationship intertwines personal finances with property rights.
Primary Types of Co-ownership
The law recognises three main structures. Choosing the right one depends on how you want ownership to behave if someone sells, dies, or defaults.
Joint Tenancy
Joint tenancy is a form of co-ownership that includes the right of survivorship. If one owner dies, their share automatically passes to the surviving owners, bypassing probate.
This structure requires all owners to have an equal share and identical interests in the property. It’s simple to set up and works well for spouses or close family members who plan to stay owners for the long term.
Tenancy in Common
Tenancy in common allows owners to hold unequal shares and to name beneficiaries for their portion.
Each co-owner can sell or mortgage their share independently, and there is no right of survivorship. This flexibility suits friends or investors who may want to exit the arrangement later or leave their share to heirs.
Shared Equity Schemes
Shared equity scheme is a hybrid model where a third party-often a government agency or private investor-provides part of the purchase price in exchange for a future share of the property's appreciation.
The homeowner (or co-owners) typically repay the equity stake when they sell, refinance, or after a set term. Shared equity can lower the upfront cash needed, but the future profit split must be clearly defined.
Legal Framework and Agreements
Regardless of the type, a written co-ownership agreement is vital. The document should cover:
- Each party’s ownership percentage.
- How mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs are split.
- Procedures for selling a share, adding a new owner, or handling default.
- Rights to occupy the property and any usage rules.
- Dispute resolution methods (mediation, arbitration, etc.).
Engaging a solicitor experienced in property law ensures the agreement meets local regulations. In New Zealand, the Land Transfer Act 2017 governs how titles are recorded and transferred.
Financial Mechanics: Mortgages and Contributions
Mortgage lenders evaluate co-ownership applications based on the combined income and creditworthiness of all borrowers.
Key financial points to consider:
- Loan-to-value ratio (LVR): Most lenders cap LVR at 80% for joint applications, but some may allow higher ratios if the borrowers have strong credit.
- Responsibility: In a joint tenancy mortgage, each borrower is jointly and severally liable-meaning the bank can pursue any one of them for the full debt.
- Tenancy in common: Lenders may require each owner to have a proportional mortgage share that mirrors their equity stake.
- Shared equity: The equity partner usually does not provide a traditional mortgage; instead, they receive a contractual right to a percentage of future gains.
Monthly cash flow planning should include a buffer for vacancies, unexpected repairs, and interest rate changes.
Tax Implications
Co-owners must understand how taxes affect them individually and collectively.
- Rental income: If the property is rented out, each owner reports their share of rent on their personal tax return.
- Capital gains tax (CGT): New Zealand does not have a general CGT, but the “bright‑line” rule taxes gains on residential properties sold within five years of purchase. The rule applies to each owner based on their proportion.
- Interest deductions: Mortgage interest is deductible against rental income, but not against personal occupation.
- Depreciation: Depreciable assets like furnishings can be written off, again proportionally.
Consult a tax adviser early to avoid surprises when you file.
Advantages and Pitfalls
Co-ownership can be a powerful way to get onto the property ladder, but it’s not risk‑free.
| Feature | Joint Tenancy | Tenancy in Common | Shared Equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ownership shares | Equal only | Unequal allowed | Owner + third‑party investor |
| Right of survivorship | Yes | No | No (investor’s stake defined in contract) |
| Ability to sell individual share | Requires consent of all owners | Can sell without consent (subject to agreement) | Investor may have first‑refusal clause |
| Mortgage liability | Joint and several | Proportional to equity share | Investor typically not a borrower |
| Best for | Spouses, close family | Friends, investors, blended families | First‑time buyers with low deposit |
Pros include shared down‑payment, diversified risk, and the ability to split costs. Cons involve potential conflict over decisions, complications in refinancing, and the need for a solid legal framework.
Step‑by‑Step Guide to Setting Up a Co‑ownership
- Define your goals: investment, primary residence, or a mix.
- Choose the ownership type that aligns with your long‑term plan.
- Calculate each party’s contribution and agree on percentage shares.
- Engage a solicitor to draft a comprehensive co‑ownership agreement. Make sure it covers exit strategies, buy‑out formulas, and dispute resolution.
- Apply for a mortgage. Provide all borrowers’ financial statements and agree on a proportional repayment schedule.
- Complete the title transfer with the Land Information New Zealand (LINZ) registry, ensuring the chosen ownership type is correctly recorded.
- Set up a joint bank account for recurring expenses. Automate payments for the mortgage, rates, insurance, and a reserve fund for repairs.
- Maintain open communication. Schedule quarterly reviews of the financial status and any upcoming maintenance.
Following these steps reduces the likelihood of disagreements and helps each owner stay on track.
Real‑World Example
Emily and James, a couple in Auckland, wanted to buy their first home but each could only afford a $30,000 deposit. They decided on a joint tenancy, each contributing $30,000 for a 50/50 share. Their $1.2million mortgage was split evenly, and the agreement stipulated that if either wanted to sell, the other had a right of first refusal. After five years, James received a promotion and wanted to buy Emily out. The agreement’s buy‑out formula (current market value minus remaining mortgage, divided by share) gave Emily $290,000-exactly what she needed to relocate.
This scenario shows how a well‑written agreement can smooth transitions, protect equity, and keep relationships intact.
When Co‑ownership Might Not Be Right for You
If you anticipate major life changes-like divorce, relocation, or significant shifts in income-co‑ownership can add complexity. Also, if you lack trust in the other party’s financial habits, the joint liability may expose you to risk.
In such cases, consider alternative paths: a staggered purchase (one buys, then later sells a portion), or a rental‑to‑own scheme that keeps ownership separate until you’re ready.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change a joint tenancy to a tenancy in common later?
Yes. All owners must sign a deed of variation and lodge it with the land registry. The change removes survivorship rights and allows unequal shares.
What happens to the mortgage if one co‑owner stops paying?
Because most mortgages create joint and several liability, the lender can demand full repayment from any borrower. The other owners may need to cover the shortfall or refinance.
Is a shared equity scheme considered a loan?
Technically it’s a contractual equity stake, not a traditional loan. However, the repayment terms often resemble a loan, tying payment to future property appreciation.
Do I need a separate insurance policy for co‑ownership?
A single building insurance policy covering the whole property is typical. The co‑ownership agreement should specify how premiums are split and who manages claims.
Can a co‑owner be forced to sell their share?
Only if the agreement includes a forced‑sale clause or if a court orders a sale due to default. Otherwise, a co‑owner can usually refuse to sell, which may trigger a partition action.
Understanding how co‑ownership works before you sign any paper can save you from costly disputes down the road. Use the steps and considerations above to decide which structure fits your situation, draft a solid legal agreement, and keep communication open. With the right preparation, co-ownership can turn a dream property into a shared reality.
Write a comment